If there’s one dessert that embodies the spirit of Key West, it’s undeniably the Key lime pie. This culinary treat’s oldest history starts in the Florida Keys, so it’s no wonder so many places around Key West serve this classic dessert. 

While you’re visiting Key West, you owe it to your tastebuds to try some of the best Key lime pie in the city. The team at Compass Realty is here to help; let’s take a flavorful journey into the origins of this delectable treat and discover some of the best places to savor the perfect slice of Key lime pie.

The History of the Key Lime Pie

The Key lime pie owes its existence to the tiny, tart Key limes that thrive in the subtropical climate of the Florida Keys. These small, round, and intensely flavored limes are the star ingredient in this iconic dessert, giving it a distinctive taste that sets it apart from other lime-infused pies. The pie’s roots can be traced back to the 1930s when recipes for this delicious concoction started to appear in newspapers in Florida.

The Best Places to Get Key Lime Pie in Key West

As you wander through the charming streets of Key West, you’ll quickly realize that just about every bakery and restaurant claims to have the best Key lime pie. While the debate over the ultimate pie in Key West may never be settled, a few establishments stand out.

Blue Heaven

Blue Heaven is a quirky and vibrant eatery that embodies the eclectic spirit of Key West. Nestled in a lush tropical garden, don’t be surprised to see cats and chickens roaming nearby. It’s a fun environment, one that pairs well with Key lime pie. Blue Heaven’s Key lime pie features a buttery cracker crust, freshly squeezed lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, and meringue.

Kermit’s Key Lime Shop

With two locations in Key West, a tasty Key lime pie from Kermit’s Key Lime Shop is never far away. For over 30 years, this shop has served up Key lime pies that feature a harmonious blend of tartness and sweetness. In addition to Key lime pie, Kermit’s offers a slew of additional Key lime products, including bars, cookies, candy, jams, jellies, and more. 

Tasteful Accommodations in Key West

Indulge in the best Key lime pie in Key West in the comfort of your vacation rental from Compass Realty! Our vacation rentals offer everything the discerning traveler needs for a wonderful getaway to Key West, including fully equipped kitchens. With locations throughout Key West, we have the perfect lodging options for every type of traveler. You can make a reservation online or by calling 305-292-1881.